CorrectCare

Prison Hospice Comforts the Dying, Touches the Living
by Jaime Shimkus

The first time Steve was called to the bedside of a dying inmate, he knew his role. After 36 hours of hospice training, he understood that he was to provide comfort and support as best he could but let the patient "drive the bus." Still, he was nervous, wondering if he’d be effective in helping the man.

Now, three years later and after attending many more vigils, it’s not necessarily any easier for Steve when a hospice patient, with whom he usually has developed an intimate bond, dies, but he certainly has a much better understanding of death—and of his own humanity. "One of the biggest fears in prison is that you’ll die alone," he says. "When I walk into the room and his eyes light up, it’s really rewarding."

Steve was among the first group of 19 hospice volunteers at Oregon State Penitentiary, Salem, a maximum security facility that houses about 2,000 male inmates. The program, launched in April 1999 after 20 months of preparatory work, came about after health services manager William Cahal, CCHP, attended a session on hospice at an NCCHC conference.

Since OSP is one of the few state prisons with an infirmary, it receives many of the most desperately ill patients. "We were providing very good medical care for dying patients, but since we always tout ourselves as meeting community standards I felt we should look into this hospice philosophy," says Cahal, who was nurse manager at the time.

The much-acclaimed program won NCCHC’s 2001 Program of the Year Award in recognition of its "proactive role" in preparing individuals and the system to deal with dying inmates, and in helping those inmates to experience humane, comfortable and dignified deaths.

The OSP Model
When Cahal took the idea to his managers they gave him the thumbs up but no funding to pay for a new program. Not a problem, says Cahal: "Depending on what model you use and how you set it up, it really does not require much extra money."

An interdisciplinary OSP work group did plenty of research and thought carefully about the features they’d want to incorporate. They studied other programs, incuding the one at the state penitentiary in Angola, LA, and two in Texas—the Michael state prison near Palestine and FMC Carswell in Ft. Worth.

The team felt that none of those hospices exactly suited their needs, so they created a model that blends features from other programs with their own enhancements. Of primary importance: To create a model that could be adopted by other Oregon prisons, with a single governing body to oversee the entire program. To date, three facilities offer hospice care.

Another priority was to have inmates, rather than staffers or community members, serve as hospice caregivers, says nurse manager Ted Randall, RN, who’s OSP’s volunteer coordinator. He now manages 21 volunteers, most of whom have been involved from the start.

Volunteers must meet certain criteria to take part in the program. For example, inmates convicted of sex or drug crimes are disqualified, and any who end up in disciplinary segregation are dropped

A respected community hospice trainer conducted the initial education and still meets monthly with the volunteers for refreshers and to help keep them motivated. A weekly meeting with a nurse covers matters such as how to move patients or place pillows. A third type of meeting occurs at the chapel, where volunteers work through bereavement issues with the chaplain or a social services professional.

The interdisciplinary hospice team, which includes one volunteer representative, meets weekly to discuss patient treatment plans.

Another notable aspect of the program is that terminally ill inmates live in their cells as long as possible. "We start them on pain medication if they need it and assign a volunteer to visit them. When the disease progresses to the point where they can’t live there anymore, we bring them to the infirmary," says Cahal.

Those in the last stages of life may be moved to a room that affords more privacy. With murals on the walls and furnished with a couch and chair, a television, VCR and CD player (most of which were donated, Cahal points out), the setting is more comfortable for patients and visitors.

Visitation rules are quite relaxed for hospice patients, and may vary depending on what’s appropriate for any given patient. The volunteers may visit 24 hours, family members, including children, may visit daily, and even inmate "family" and friends can visit. In the last day or two of life, volunteers and family can remain at the bedside continually.

Patients also are granted special requests, such as favorite foods.

Universal Acceptance
Cahal says that while the hospice has been largely trouble-free, the planners did make one misstep: they failed to adequately consider the attitudes of the health care workers.

"We went to great lengths to educate the custody staff, but took it for granted that the health care staff would accept it," says Cahal. Some nurses felt their role in "health care" did not extend to the dying; others said the inmates didn’t deserve hospice. Deeper discussion of hospice philosophy and good experiences with the program have overcome those grumblings.

As important, the hospice has been embraced by those terminal patients who are ready to accept death, by their families, by the prison population at large (many of whom used to suspiciously view the infirmary as the "place of death") and by volunteers.

For Steve, who’s serving a life sentence but hopes for parole, the experience has been transformational: "It has touched parts of me that hadn’t been touched in many years. It raised questions about my values, and showed me that some things I thought were important really aren’t. Now I realize that family and friends and close relationships are what’s truly important."


A Growing Movement

The Oregon State Penitentiary wasn’t the first prison with a formal end-of-life care program. That distinction is shared by two facilities—the Medical Center for Federal Prisoners in Springfield, MO, and the California Medical Facility in Vacaville, CA—that, independently of each other, began to develop such programs 15 years ago.

But the prison hospice movement didn’t pick up steam until the late 1990s, says Liz Craig, resource coordinator for the GRACE Project, a Volunteers of America initiative that promotes high quality end-of-life care for terminally ill inmates. "The AIDS epidemic started it all," she says. "With so many patients dying, there was interest from both inmates and administrators."

According to a GRACE Project report, prison deaths in the United States totaled 1,500 in 1987, but reached nearly 3,500 in 1995. That figure has fallen somewhat since then due to declines in AIDS-related death rates, but at the same time, deaths from natural causes have been rising.

In response, more and more prisons are developing end-of-life programs, the report shows. In 2001, 19 states had at least one formal program and 14 more had programs under development. Three years earlier, those figures stood at 11 and 4, respectively.

But a looming danger, says Craig, is that financial hardships at many prison systems may put these programs in jeopardy.

Model Programs
The hospice at OSP became a national model when it was selected as one of four demonstration sites for the GRACE Project. The others are McCain Correctional Hospital Hospice, operated by the North Carolina Department of Corrections; Coxsackie Regional Medical Unit Hospice, operated by the New York Department of Correctional Services; and the Federal Medical Center Carswell in Texas.

What does it mean to be a demonstration site? Craig says these geographically dispersed programs were chosen because they feature "enhancements" that set them apart. OSP, for instance, developed a bereavement program for inmates, family and staff. As models, all must be willing to field lots of phone calls and give tours to visitors.

Profiles of the four sites can be found on the GRACE Project Web site, along with extensive resource materials including standards of practice for correctional hospice, "how-to" advice and an annotated bibliography. Visit www.graceprojects.org.

About the Author: Jaime Shimkus is NCCHC publications editor.

[This article first appeared in the Spring 2002 issue of CorrectCare.]

 
About NCCHC  |  CCHP Certification  |  Publications & Products  |  Supplier Opportunities
Accreditation  |  Education & Conferences  |  Resources & Links  |  Buyers Guide

Home  |  Contact Us  |  Site Map